Quick answer: Flat rate charges one blended percentage on every card, no matter what it actually costs the processor. Interchange-plus charges you the real wholesale interchange cost plus a fixed markup, so you see exactly what your processor earns.
If you cannot read your statement, you cannot tell whether you are overpaying. The two pricing models below explain most of the difference, and a five-minute check of your statement will tell you which one you are on.
What is interchange-plus pricing?
Interchange-plus pricing is a model where you pay the real wholesale cost of each transaction, plus a fixed markup from your processor. Nothing is blended together. Nothing is hidden.
This model breaks that "real wholesale cost" down into three parts.
- Interchange is the fee set by the card networks and paid to the bank that issued the customer's card. It is not negotiable. The networks publish their interchange tables, so the wholesale cost of every card is public.
- Network assessments are small fees the card networks charge on top of interchange. These are also pass-through, meaning the card networks set them and your processor simply passes them along to you at no markup.
- Processor markup is the only piece your processor actually controls, and the only piece you can negotiate. This is where interchange-plus pricing earns its name: interchange, plus a markup.
Think of interchange like the wholesale price of a product. Your processor is the retailer, and the markup is their margin. With interchange-plus pricing, you can see the wholesale price and the margin listed separately, line by line.
What is flat rate pricing?
Flat rate pricing charges you one blended percentage on every transaction, regardless of the card type. A debit card and a rewards credit card cost you the same rate, even though they do not cost the processor the same amount.
On the plus side, it is simple. You know your rate before you even swipe a card.
But simplicity has a price. A basic credit card costs about 1.51% plus $0.10 in interchange when taken in person, and a regulated debit card costs far less. If your flat rate is 2.9%, your processor keeps the difference on every one of those sales.
Example: same month, two pricing models
Take a hypothetical merchant processing $50,000 in a month, with a card mix of debit and basic rewards cards. The flat rate here is 2.9%, Stripe's standard online rate.
| Pricing model | Rate structure | Monthly cost |
|---|---|---|
| Flat rate | 2.9% blended on all cards | $1,450 |
| Interchange-plus | About 1.6% average interchange + 0.30% markup | $950 |
That is a $500 difference in a single month, on identical sales. The flat rate did not change based on the card mix. The interchange-plus total did, because it reflected what the cards actually cost.
Both sides leave out per-transaction fees for simplicity. A flat-rate plan typically adds about $0.30 per transaction, and interchange-plus adds the interchange per-transaction fee plus a markup of about $0.10. Including them would widen the gap slightly in favor of interchange-plus, not narrow it.
Now flip the card mix. If this same merchant processed mostly premium rewards and corporate cards (interchange around 2.5%), the gap narrows right down. The card mix, not the pricing model alone, decides which model works better.
If your statement shows mostly debit and basic cards and you are on a flat rate, that gap is probably real money. Send us your statement and we will tell you what interchange-plus would cost for your mix, free. Request a free assessment.
Which pricing model should you choose?
When flat rate makes more sense
- Your volume is low
- Your card mix skews expensive
- Predictability matters for your business
When interchange-plus makes more sense
- Your volume is higher
- Your card mix is debit-heavy
- Your customers tend to use low-cost cards
Choose interchange-plus if transparency and cost control matter most to you. Choose flat rate if you would rather pay for simplicity and a statement you never have to decode.
How to check your own statement
Grab your last statement and use these steps to figure out which pricing model you are on. If you want the line-by-line version, here is how to read your processing statement.
- One consistent rate. If every transaction, regardless of card type, shows the same percentage, you are likely on flat-rate pricing.
- Itemized interchange. If your statement lists interchange fees separately by card category (debit, rewards, corporate, etc.), you are on interchange-plus pricing.
- A clearly labeled processor markup. Interchange-plus statements will show the markup as its own line item, separate from interchange.
- Tiered pricing language. Watch for terms like "qualified," "mid-qualified," and "non-qualified." This is a third model, often more expensive than either flat rate or interchange-plus, and it is designed to be confusing.
- Your effective rate. Divide your total monthly fees by your total monthly processing volume. If your provider quoted you 2%, but your effective rate comes out to 3.2%, something between the quote and the statement does not add up.
Calculate your effective rate, and you will see what you are really paying.
Frequently asked questions
Is interchange-plus always cheaper than flat rate?
Not always. If premium rewards or corporate cards dominate your card mix, flat rate pricing can match or beat interchange-plus. If your mix leans toward debit and basic consumer cards, interchange-plus can be cheaper.
What are the current interchange-plus rates?
There is no single rate to quote. Interchange varies by card type, transaction method, and merchant category, and the markup on top of it varies by processor. The only way to know your real rate is to look at your own itemized statement.
Can I negotiate interchange fees?
No. Interchange is set by the card networks, not your processor. The only negotiable piece of interchange-plus pricing is the markup your processor adds on top.
Can I switch from flat rate to interchange-plus pricing?
In most cases, yes, though it depends on your processor and your current agreement. Some processors require a new application or a short waiting period. Check your contract terms or ask your processor directly.
Flat rate vs. interchange-plus pricing is not a question with one right answer. It depends on your volume, your card mix, and how much you value predictability over savings.
What matters is that you actually know which one you are on, so you can make an informed decision.
Send us your most recent statement and we will walk through it line by line, including your effective rate and whether interchange-plus would cost less for your card mix. The review is free, and there is no obligation to switch. Request a free assessment or contact us to get started.
Have a complex payment problem?
Tell us what's going on — a senior person will take a look and reply within one business day.

